Verified answer

Yess....

I am an ardent Edward fan. I mean, why would anybody choose Jacob over Edward? Edward is:

- Better looking

- More romantic

- More selfless

- Self-sacrificing

- Musical

Plus, she loved him first. At first, in Twilight, he was sweet, but he really got in my nerves in Eclipse. I'm glad that he helped Bella out in New Moon, but he kept pushing her to choose him and hurting her. If he loved her, he'd let her go. "If you love something, let it go. If it was meant to be, it'll come back to you."

I was really mad she kissed him back and fell in love with him. For heaven's sake, she was engaged!

This a question in disguise. So I'm kind of guessing that I'm answering a "Edward or Jacob?" question.

I formerly liked Jacob. *But he was ruined in Breaking Dawn when he imprinted on Renesmee, Bella and Edward's child. He's now an incestuous pedophile. But before, he was the only REAL guy in the book. He had flaws, hopes, dreams. He was the only person to have realistic expectations. He knew how to have fun. The rest of the characters, except Emmett, are a bunch of wet blankets.

That might explain the reason why I still haven't finished reading Breaking Dawn.

Hahaha, I got to Jake's chapter and decided to stop.

Yeah, I know. It's pretty crazy how people can get all angry over a nonfictional character~

Just blame it on Stephenie Meyer's godly writing skills =p

And I agree with you! I seriously wanted to throw the book at the wall when she fell in love with Jacob -_-

I like them both in different ways.

I want Edward to be with Bella, that is how it is suppose to be. But I wanted Jacob in her life. Breaking Dawn made everything good!!! = )

i was like you when i read eclipse! i hated jacob and i thought he was ruining bella and edward's relationship.

for me i love edward cullen more then jacob black because he is soo sweet and kind. he would do anything for bella

there both great

jacob is the a person you could have fun and do stupid things with

and edward is a person that keeps you in check but is a great loving person

so i like them both

and yes i know there both fictional ^_^

edward! i read some of new moon and im glad that she and edward are doing great!

edward all the wayyy!!!

but jacob aint bad, but i don't lyk him.

edward is sooo frikin hot!(fictional or not!)