I'm a 17 year old metalhead from Middle GA, & my first bought album was Operation: Mindcrime, I always treated is as a gem, b/c of the concept of the album. I bough my 7th album Iced Earth's Night of the Stormrider, which I thought had a stronger concept, but I just didn't think it was as memorable as Queensrÿche's Magnum Opus. My 23rd album I bought was Mercyful Fate's Melissa, while their debut was astounding, I did at times (with no disrespect to King Diamond) thought his vocals were over-the-top, & concept not as provoking as the other two previously mentioned. My other two metal concept albums are Fates Warning's The Spectre Within, which I believe is more tight in instrumentalisation and sound (not to mention Arch's Bruce Dickinson-esque vocal style), Saturnus' magnum opus Paradise Belongs to You, which is the most brutal sounding. I was still hard-pressed to even consider those great metal concept albums to be as memorable, ground-breaking & energetic, as well as interesting as Operation: Mindcrime. So, my question to you is Operation: Mindcrime the GREATEST concept album ever. Not familiar w/ concept albums outside the metal genre so please feel free to suggest some, as I am a open-minded metalhead (If there is such a thing)
Update:Yes, I've heard of Dream Theater, personally I didn't really understand why they made a whole concept album off a whole completely other album but, The thing that bothers me w/ DT was there inability to top Images & Words, & from Octavarium & the leaving of Portnoy & Petrucci, makes me feel like the legacy of that band is going to end up like Sepultura a completely different band, altogether. But that's just my opinion
Answers & Comments
Verified answer
I would put forth "Metropolis Part 2: Scenes from a Memory" by Dream Theater as the best concept album ever. I'd be surprised if you'd never heard of Dream Theater, they're a pretty good prog metal band. I would suggest looking up the entire album, or at least the song "Home." Before you listen to it you should probably listen to "Metropolis Pt. 1" by them, so you get the background. It's basically about a guy who travels back in time to solve a murder, mixed in with a love triangle involving 2 brothers (don't worry no queer stuff). A lot of the songs on the album taken by themselves have deep messages as well. If you like instrumentation, a lot of the songs on all of their albums have extended technical instrumentals.
Edit: Yeah, I know what you mean, I'm still a big Portnoy fan; Petrucci hasn't left though. But I guess that's kinda what has to happen for it to be prog; if they don't change over the years, it becomes boring. I think they've come a long ways since I&W, in terms of expression. A lot of their newer stuff has more emotion and real life experience behind it than, say, "Under a Glass Moon." But yeah, I guess we'll see where it goes.
What do you mean they did no longer catch on? I actual have all of those in my track series, and that i oftentimes hear human beings speaking approximately them : darkish component of The Moon - crimson Floyd Thick As A Brick - Jethro Tull conflict new child - Jethro Tull Mike Oldfield :~ Tubular Bells Tubular Bells II Tubular Bells III Ommadawn Hergest Ridge Incantations Admitedly, the assumption album is in many cases got here across interior the 'prog rock' style, and you do no longer see lots of them at present. maximum track listeners at present purely don't have the *{will no longer be able to think of of the main suitable be conscious!}* to relish this way of track. all of them choose 2 minute throw-away bland nonsense ~ they are actually not keen to look deeper into track.